sentential ambiguity examples Navigation

We call the set of sentential forms that can be derived from S of a grammar G, the sentential language of G, denoted S(G). and by Schwanenflugel and Shoben. A sentential form in T* is called a sentence. A set of productions (P). The produc… To further emphasize the sentential import of his commander's suicide, Titinius laments that Cassius "hast misconstrued every thing" (5.3.84). 2 Vocabulary We need to review some definitions before we can proceed: grammar a set of rules by which valid sentences in a language are constructed. predicting the resolution of the commonly studied Direct Object/Sentential Complement (DO/SC) ambiguity. Flying planes can be dangerous. Considered only as … Example 2.5 For taking any string xay can be parsed by using the first or the second production of C, so that vertical ambiguity exists Definition 2.6: Horizontal ambiguity then means that, when parsing a string according to a production, there is choice of how There are ambiguous expressions that involve a combination of these types of ambiguity. E + E E * E E E + E * E E E (a) (b) It could mean "(p → q) r", or "p → (q r)", which are not equivalent. Ambiguity in context-free grammarsis a recurring problem in language design and parser generation, as well as in applications where gram-mars are used as models of real-world physical structures. pen. Two types of ambiguity ( lexical (semantic) ambiguity ( due to ambiguity in the meaning of one or more of the words in the sentence: a word or an expression can be interpreted in more than one way because it has multiple meanings ( This will make you . C → c . If every string in L(G) has at most one parse tree, G is said to be unambiguous. The meanings of the different interpretations should be clear. 1. nonterminal a grammar symbol that can be replaced/expanded to a sequence of symbols. If the grammar is not ambiguous, then it is called unambiguous. ing. For example, the sentence: the shooting’ ‘They hated the fact that the hunters were shot.’ This is an example of ambiguous grammar. 1. A → a. Consider a string w = a. However, a further source of information that can influence sentence interpretation is the context, linguistic or otherwise, in which the ambiguous sentence occurs. S → aS / a / ∈. N is a set of non-terminal symbols. Lexical ambiguity, also known as semantic ambiguity, occurs when a sentence has an ambiguous word or phrase (which has more than one possible meaning). This phenomenon is a result of polysemy. Take the ambiguous words presented in 1–2 as examples; researchers are interested in whether the ‘fruit’ meaning of the homonymous word date would be activated when it is presented in 1a and whether the ‘content’ meaning of the polysemous word film would be activated when it is presented in a sentential context like 2a. Lexical ambiguity presents two or more possible meanings within a single word. If every Context Free Grammar G with Language L = L (G) is ambiguous, then L is said to be inherently ambiguous Language. Ambiguity is a property of grammar not languages. T is a set of terminals where N ∩ T = NULL. Here also, each string have its leftmost derivation and rightmost derivation exactly same. (1) Mary bumped into [NP1 the busboy] and [NP2 the waiter] last Saturday night. Then the child was told that he would be hearing a number of sentences on the tape recorder, some of which would have only one meaning and some two meanings. B → b. Which sentential node it adjoins to determines its semantic scope. In this example, the baby could be wrapped in the green blanket or the woman could be using the green blanket as an instrument to hold the baby. ; The syntax analyzer has one recursive procedure for each nonterminal u.; A sentence of a grammar is ambiguous if there exists two syntax trees for it. Consider the following grammar-S → ABC. You will become . In this section, we will first see the definition of context-free grammar and introduce terminologies used in parsing technology. an ambiguity; it does not need an additional account of why the ambiguity is not resolved in a maximally charitable way in examples like (2); and, contrary to lore, it is not refuted byMcKay & van Inwagen’s (1977) example (4). 5. 3. sentential form • A sentence is a sentential form that has only terminal symbols • A leftmost derivation is one in which the leftmost nonterminal in each sentential form is the one that is expanded • A derivation may be neither leftmost nor rightmost Example • Given … "terminal" is supposed to conjure The derivation tree is also called a parse tree. in V* are called sentential forms. The potential direct object, his lines, is a great example of something that an actor might forget, and thus strongly supports the direct object interpretation. Non-terminals are syntactic variables that denote sets of strings. They hated the shooting of the ‘They hated the hunters who did hunters. (14)Andy didn’t read a book. Ambiguous grammar: A CFG is said to ambiguous if there exists more than one derivation tree for the given input string i.e., more than one L eft M ost D erivation T ree (LMDT) or R ight M ost D erivation T ree (RMDT). Hyponymy One word indicates category of things. Context-Free Grammar Introduction. They constructed sentences which biased either the dominant or subordinant meaning of an ambiguous word as in examples (1) and (2): terminal an actual word in a language; these are the symbols in a grammar that cannot be replaced by anything else. Sentential and discourse topic effects on lexical ambiguity processing: An eye movement examination KATHERINE S. BINDER Mount Holyoke College,South Hadley, Massachusetts Models of lexical ambiguity resolution posit a role for context, but this construct has remained rel- Total 6 derivations exist for string w. The following 4 derivations are neither leftmost nor rightmost- Derivation-01: S → ABC → aBC (Using A → a) → aBc (Using C → c) → abc (Using B → b) Derivation-02: S → ABC → AbC (Using B → b) Negation is the only one of o ur operators with a pre-defined scope: namely, the first meaningful proposition (simple or compound) to its right. In addition, forgot is used much more often with a direct object than a sentential complement. The non-terminals define sets of strings that help define the language generated by the grammar. The DO/SC ambiguity occurs in sentence fragments such as in example (1), where the post-verbal noun phrase can either be the direct object of the verb, as in (2), or the subject of a sentential complement, as in (3). Therefore, when a comprehender Another example of misinterpretation, and one of the most striking in the play, is the death of Cinna the poet in act 3, scene 3. Lexical Ambiguity. This is also known as semantic ambiguity. nExample 5.13: L = {a nb cm} ∪ {anbmcm}. The example they cite here is the ambiguous sentence: "The old men and women sat on the bench." For example, Chomsky’s classic example (5) involves a subject/object ambiguity analogous to (4), as well as syncretism of the –ing suffix, resulting in syntactic ambiguity regarding the grammatical category of flying. If the grammar has ambiguity, then it is not good for compiler construction. Since two different parse trees exist, so grammar is ambiguous. studied coordination ambiguity is shown in examples (1) and (2). An example from Tom Sant’s book Persuasive Business Proposals : “Featuring plug-in circuit boards, we can strongly endorse this server’s flexibility and growth potential.” (2) [S1 Phrase ambiguity; 1. pretty boys and girls Sentence ambiguity; 2.The boy kicked the girl with the wig. Lexical ambiguity is the presence of two or more possible meanings for a single word. It's also called semantic ambiguity or homonymy. It differs from syntactic ambiguity, which is the presence of two or more possible meanings within a sentence or sequence of words. The men are old, but are the women also old? Donald Ressler: "The third guard, he's in the hospital. Paraphrase Sentences have same meaning. Slide 7 Entailment Relation which the truth of one sentence implies the truth of another. In SL, capital letters are used to represent basic sentences. Sentence letters. 2. If the grammar is not ambiguous, then it is called unambiguous. If the grammar has ambiguity, then it is not good for compiler construction. No method can automatically detect and remove the ambiguity, but we can remove ambiguity by re-writing the whole grammar without ambiguity. S 1 |S 2 where S1 produces the strings anb cmand S 2 the strings . The semantic contexts used in studies of lexical ambiguity resolution seem to differ from the feature priming contexts used by Tabossi et al. 3. No method can automatically detect and remove the ambiguity, but we can remove ambiguity by re-writing the whole grammar without ambiguity. Context-Free Languages Hinrich Schütze CIS, LMU, 2013-11-25 Slides based on RPI CSCI 2400 Thanks to Costas Busch * Definition: A context-free grammar is ambiguous if some string has: two or more derivation trees * In other words: A context-free grammar is ambiguous if some string has: two or more leftmost derivations (or rightmost) * Why do we care about ambiguity? It is the simple way to show how the derivation can be done to obtain some string from a given set of production rules. We observe that there is a simple linguistic characterization of the grammar ambiguity problem, and we show how to exploit this by presenting an ambiguity say that G is ambiguous is there is a string in T that has more than one parse tree. Existence of ‘ambiguity’ in natural languages. Slide 5 Types of Sentential: Ambiguity A sentence hasmore than one possible syntactic structure. Two examples of sentential ambiguity, one phonological and one surface structure, were discussed with the aid of accompanying pic-tures. For Example . For example: “Do you believe in clubs for young people?” someone asked W.C. Fields. They explain that if the women sitting on the bench are not elderly, when the word "men" is spoken it will be relatively long in duration, while "the stressed syllable in 'women' will have a steep rise in speech contour ." De Copia, and Sentential Ambiguity Jeffrey J.Yu In Shakespeares Julius Caesar, immediately after the assassination, Brutus and Cassius make the following metadramatic allusion: Caesar: How many ages hence Shall this our lofty scene be acted over, In states unborn, and accents yet unknown! We see a lot of this in puns and other forms of wordplay. Example 5.13: The language L={a nb cm} {anbmcm} 2.3Scope ambiguity • A generalized quantifier can be raised to adjoin to any sentential node. Example 1: Let us consider a grammar G with the production rule Notice that the ambiguity depends on whether the noun phrase following the conjunction is part of a complex object like in example (1), or the subject of a conjoined sentence as in example (2). Parse tree follows the precedence of operators. Structural ambiguity: The same sequence of words have two or more meanings based on the way they are combined. The syntax analyzer calls the scanner when it needs a new symbol. ; A parse of a sentential form is the construction of a derivation and possibly a syntax tree for it. What Is The Difference Between Lexical and Structural Ambiguity? 'He cut his hand off.'" Example: The terminal string a+a a has two parse trees: I a I a I a I a I a I a + * * + E E E E E E E E E E (a) (b) 169 burning sensation. E ⇒ E ∗E ⇒ E +E ∗E. Consider for example, an influential study by Onifer and Swinney [1981]. One example of a global ambiguity is "The woman held the baby in the green blanket." clever. Terminals are the basic symbols from which strings are formed. Consider a string w = abc. A set of tokens, known as terminal symbols(Σ). Now, consider the following grammar-. Three simple examples will illustrate some different types of scope ambiguity and their representation in an informal first order predicate logic, using restrictions on quantifiers and an infix notation for sentential formulas. Brutus: How many times shall Caesar bleed in sport, Derivation Tree. an ambiguous sentence is encountered, such as, for example, “John kicked the ball to the left” (where John could either have kicked the left one of two balls, or kicked the ball to the left instead of to the right), the interpreter will choose one of the meanings and maintain it until Derivation tree is a graphical representation for the derivation of the given production rules for a given CFG. Thus far, the only information we have considered that can influence the interpretation of sentential ambiguity has been information derived from within the sentence itself. 2. E ⇒ E +E ⇒ E +E ∗E. Slide 6 Contradiction Two sentences cannot be both true. can forget things. The set of all sentences that can be derived from S of a grammar G … Definition − A context-free grammar (CFG) consisting of a finite set of grammar rules is a quadruple (N, T, P, S) where. It's a lexical ambiguity. 1) Structural ambiguity What is ambiguity: a phrase or a word has more than one distinct meaning. 2. smart. ( Liz bought a . If every grammar that generates L is ambiguous, then the language is called inherently ambiguous. nThe way to make a CFG for this L somehow has to involve the step S ? A context-free grammar has four components: 1. Since the time of Pāṇini, at least, linguists have described the grammars of languages in terms of their block structure, and described how sentences are recursivelybuilt up from smaller phrases, and eventually individual words or word elements. A set of non-terminals(V). First, the ambiguous words occur in sentential contexts that bias their dominant meaning, but prime no specific feature of it (e.g., "The man had to be at five o'clock at the port for a very important meeting").2 Second, the related visual words are associates to one meaning of the ambiguous item, but do not denote any feature of it (e.g., SEA: dominant, contextually congruent; LIQUEUR: subordinate, … Example Grammar Ambiguity 18 Inherently AmbiguousInherently Ambiguous nLanguages that can only be generated by ambiguous grammars are inherently ambiguous. You will get a . Berlin cut his hand off." Some structural ambiguity is the result of writing errors, such as misplaced modifiers. Aram Mojtabai: "No, no. Ambiguity in Languages Definition 5.6: If L is context-free language there exists an unambiguous grammar, then L is said to be ambiguous. Locally ambiguous For a given grammar G, Two sentential form and | are vertically ambiguous. For example, "p → q r" is ambiguous. 2 Complex operators show that SDA is not generally valid An essential property of these block structures is that logical units never overlap. 2. 1 Removing Ambiguity From Grammars Example 1: Consider the following grammar for expressions: E → I/E +E/E ∗E/(E) I → a/b/Ia/Ib/I0/I1 Example 2: Consider the sentential form E + E ∗ E. It has two derivations from E (see grammar in Example 1): 1. – a book ¡not: ‘There is a book xsuch that Andy didn’t read x’ S DP a book x e S notS DP Andy VP V tr read x e